UpSpeed PowerLine Network Review

Networking 66 Page 13 of 14 Published by

teaser

Result analysis

Test Results

bestcom_powerline_netthru1.jpgSorry about the small size. Not allowed more than 425x500 pixels

Comparing speeds it is obvious that a pure Ethernet 10Mbps network performs much better than the powerline, but the wireless network performs slightly worse on that front. It must be said that this is 802.11b WLAN we are talking about, the newer 802.11g WLANs are much faster at around 20Mbps+.

bestcom_powerline_netthru2.jpg 

The second table is just to show you how 100Mbps compares !

 

bestcom_powerline_ping.jpg

We can see just how variable the ping times can be for wireless, powerline technology is much better in this respect.

 


What do the results say?

Three facts that you should take away from the results.

  1. Low latency. Even in bad conditions the latency was on average, less than 10ms
  2. Stability, despite fridges, boilers, and TVs clicking on and off most of the time, the connection is pretty solid.
  3. Data rate. Although not making a dent on the ever common 100Mbps home network, 2-5Mbps is a good transfer rate for the common small home network. A good rival to 802.11b networks but not 802.11g.

What dont the results say?

Using only one adapter means that we cant determine what the performance might be reduced to if we were to run several powerline adapters in the home.

How reliable are these products during an electrical storm? Hopefully there is some spike protection built in to each device, but since the guidelines state that you shouldnt plug the units into surge protection sockets (presumably for performance) we must trust the manufacturer that this wont destroy any hardware in our pc.

 

The most important point that the results defiantly dont draw, is how well this kit is going to work in your home since every house is different. The results show a bad working condition, a good working condition and ideal working conditions, its up to you to make the buying decision.

Share this content
Twitter Facebook Reddit WhatsApp Email Print