Google: Antivirus Scanners are Pretty Much Useless
Click here to post a comment for Google: Antivirus Scanners are Pretty Much Useless on our message forum
jbmcmillan
jbmcmillan
kinggavin
anti virus are pretty much useless data collection is more of a risk than getting hacked , you can say an anti virus is ok for people who have no common sense and click and download anything , but google microsoft facebook your isp there all in the money game and worse than hackers really coz they do anything to get your personal data, and when they harvest data like this and get every drop off info about you if they get hacked its gonna expose all your info even bank accounts you have never used online ,best thing you can do to protect yourself on the internet is use a good quality vpn to try stop data collection
go4brendon
CPC_RedDawn
inb4 google release their own antivirus software..... :P
CrazY_Milojko
http://www.classicshell.net/ for one of our clients to install it on his Win8.1 and right after download (before even starting the install process) KIS heuristic protection on my rig screamed that something suspicious is going on with this file, WTF!? Clients rig with Win8.1 + Windows Defender, same official site and same file downloaded few minutes later: Windows Defender didn't found nothing. Earlier that day, some few hours before, I've already downloaded CS4.3.0 from the same site and KIS didn't found nothing. Just to be on the safe side I've decided to digg that previously downloaded CS4.3.0 installation file from one of my USB drives, copied it to my rig with KIS: nothing, KIS said file is safe. Used that earlier downloaded installation on clients rig and everything went fine.
Few days later, bang!!! Aug 2nd, 2016 - The Classic Shell download service was hacked
KIS saved my ass that day thats for sure...
The real reason why I'm using KAV at home and KIS at work is because from my personall experience most of users here don't give a f**k what's going on with their PCs, where they or their kids surf on the web, what they download, where they plug in their USB flash-drives, USB hard-drives... PCs at schools here are INSANELY INFECTED with all kinds of nasty viruses, my kids already know that because EVERY SINGLE TIME when they bring some of their USB flash-drive to finish school projects at at home all of those drives are infected with only God knows what. KAV on kids computers is doing it's job just perfect to keep those rigs safe, unlike PCs of most of their friends who need to complete reinstall their rigs every once in a while because all kinds of nasty stuff rendered those rigs to the point of unusability every few months.
Also I don't thrust ANYONE who brings his USB flash-drive or USB hard-drive to me to copy/print some stuff: "...it's viruss-free, don't worry mate!..." My ass virus-free!!! 7-8 of of 10 times those drives are infected with all kinds of viruses, autorun malware...
So for those who said you don't need AV software, common sense is the best protection and what not: good luck with that, either you keep your PCs under the glass bell or you don't have friends/people around you who every now and then bring their portable storage to plug in those into some of your PCs for all kinds of reasons.
What?!
:funny:
Dude, you just made my day...
Personally, I don't remember last time I've stumbled on virus while surfing the web (OK, I remember, read further), I'm visiting some 10, 15 sites that are quite safe, download programs only from manufacturers sites and KAV (home) and KIS (work) doesn't have much to do while I'm using the computers, but...
But few months ago on one of my rigs at work I've downloaded latest Classic Shell 4.3.0 from official site schmidtbag
kinggavin
money is the only thing really u can lose if a personal pc gets hacked and they can only get that password u have used on that pc so if you have a credit card bank account u just opened to use online and only put money on there the day you gonna buy something and rest time just keep a little money on there ur never gonna lose much even u did get hacked the issue for me is main bank acounts which never are used online with your savings money in the only way u can lose money there is by the bank getting hacked or data collection thats the biggest risk i care about
fry178
@SirDremor
then why are ppl walking into stores like microcenter/bestbuy/staples etc, to get infections removed?
from around 800 computers that i fixed in a 7 month time frame (when actively working as tech), more than 80% were infected.
If AVs would work (out of the box) that would not be the case.
But the best joke was their scanning software (Norton), which missed around 50-80% of spy/malware running on the tested system, when malwarebytes/superantispyware had no trouble finding/removing it.
So for most users it would NOT be an improvement using an AV, if the machine still gets infected..
And no, comparing software to condoms is a joke. i can secure wipe my system drive and clean install any OS 1 min later.
How does that work with STD or pregnancy? right...
Stormyandcold
As long as back doors are built into the os, nothing will ever be 100% secure, never mind the vulnerabilities that are found.
We live in a paranoid world where the higher-ups want access to everything we do that they can get their hands on. The more security we want, the less freedom we have. There is no compromise here.
This is justified when they find terrorists amongst the populace and tell us they've been following them for X amount of time and caught X number of terrorists plotting X number of terrorist activities.
I don't think it's possible to go "off the grid" if you continue to use the internet in any way.
TheDeeGee
Cool story, but i will continue to use NOD32.
The Laughing Ma
So correct me if I am wrong, if someone came here saying they had symptoms of a malware or virus the general advice here would be to do nothing? Correct me if I am wrong but the general solution for folk asking for this advice will be do a scan with THIS program or do a scan with THAT program and more often than not a lot of these programs come with their own real time protection systems. So what are the folk that say these programs are useless really saying, do nothing if you suspect malware or virus? Reinstall and start over?
kinggavin
rl66
Google (or alphabet) represent all that is bad and evil in science and internet...
i agree on one point: viruses are less used since plishing ransomware and net attack are more lucrative :bang:
a good knowledge is the best AV you can have. for the rest you have avast, kaspersky, nod etc
(yes QT, java, flash and adobe craps are obsolete and massive hole in system security too)
PrMinisterGR
Most of the conversation in the thread is completely off. He was talking about servers, or systems that run infrastructure, not desktop users.
"Those things, are according to Bilby, virus scanners and intrusion detection systems. Instead he wants “security types” to focus on whitelisting, hardware security keys and dynamic access rights"
In systems like that, or anything with a specific purpose, whitelisting and correct access rights are orders of magnitude safer than leaving things open and hope for the best that the AV can do.
In modern computers with users that don't pirate, a router-based adblock/malware domain block would be much more effective than any antivirus.
And for people who love to live dangerously, a list like that on the router/computer level, along with a preemptive scan of everything with Malwarebytes and a check on the startup tab of Task Manager and in the Task Scheduler, should cover 99.999% of malware. If it doesn't, then a government is after you and good luck with that 😀
schmidtbag
kinggavin
nick0323
Java/Flash etc. are borderline pointless. Java even more so as v10 will be their last version. Everyone knows that - talk about stating the obvious.
Funny comment coming from someone at Google/Alphabet - how many holes have been fixed in Android over the last year then? What about your massive fragmentation problem? No? Ok!
PrMinisterGR
tsunami231
flash is no longer installed on my pc's neither is java
I Still wont go on internet without adblocker, and AV better to have it and not need it, then need it and not have it both can stop stupid from happening when stupid clicks things they shouldnt.
yes AV no longer as effective as they use to be, but it better then using nothing. nor was AV ever ment to be able to stop hackers.
it for virus/malware/trojan protection which again is better then using nothing.