Intel Core i9 9900KS processor review
AMD Ryzen 9 3950X review
Promo: Windows 10 Pro for $13 With Office 2016 For $33
ASUS PRIME X570 Pro review
ASUS ROG STRIX Scope keyboard review
GALAX GeForce RTX 2070 Super WTF review
ADATA Spectrix S40G 512GB NVMe M.2 SSD review
Red Dead Redemption 2: PC graphics performance benchmark review
XFX Radeon RX 5700 XT THICC III Ultra review
Promo: URcdkey Halloween sale Windows 10 Pro for 11$
AMD Radeon RX 5700 and 5700 XT review
Posted by: on: 07/07/2019 02:00 PM [
311 comment(s) ]
In this review, we look at the two new graphics cards released by AMD, the Radeon 5700 and 5700 XT. Both cards are based on the new NAVI GPU, fabricated at a 7nm node and capable of battling with NVIDIA's GeForce RTX 2060 and 2070. Join us in an in-depth review of these new 8GB GDDR6 based graphics cards.
Read article
Advertisement
Tagged as:
amd
pages 1 2 3 4 > »
Fox2232
Senior Member
Posts: 9755
Senior Member
Posts: 9755
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:29 PM
I was right in my assumption made based on architecture description that RX 5700 (XT) will be great on 1080p.
@Hilbert Hagedoorn :
has following:
Memory
16 GB (4x 4MB) 2400 MHz DDR4
32 GB 4x8MB) 3200 MHz DDR4
= = = =
Btw. I intend to order 5700 XT.
...It is still not listed on our shops.
I was right in my assumption made based on architecture description that RX 5700 (XT) will be great on 1080p.
@Hilbert Hagedoorn :
Test Environment & Equipment
has following:
Memory
16 GB (4x 4MB) 2400 MHz DDR4
32 GB 4x8MB) 3200 MHz DDR4
= = = =
Btw. I intend to order 5700 XT.
...It is still not listed on our shops.
Alex13
Senior Member
Posts: 2310
Senior Member
Posts: 2310
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:31 PM
Yeah, I'd be tempted by this the XT at 350 (partner custom AIB)
Yeah, I'd be tempted by this the XT at 350 (partner custom AIB)
Astyanax
Senior Member
Posts: 3658
Senior Member
Posts: 3658
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:33 PM
looks like that dent in the shroud did nothing for accoustics.
looks like that dent in the shroud did nothing for accoustics.
Hyderz
Senior Member
Posts: 112
Senior Member
Posts: 112
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:34 PM
this gpu is pretty amazing from the result, and it cost $399 which is not great value card but its certainly not bad too.
As a consumer, i think i will skip the RTX and RTX super series and current radeon lineup.
Not gonna consider both parties because i have a GTX 1070ti, there are currently only 4 rtx titles and a benchmark, and performance wise the 1070ti still holds up.
For those upgrading from 9xx series or 1060 and lower, the radeon 5700xt will provide a nice upgrade or if you want nvidia rtx 2070 super is the card to get.
this gpu is pretty amazing from the result, and it cost $399 which is not great value card but its certainly not bad too.
As a consumer, i think i will skip the RTX and RTX super series and current radeon lineup.
Not gonna consider both parties because i have a GTX 1070ti, there are currently only 4 rtx titles and a benchmark, and performance wise the 1070ti still holds up.
For those upgrading from 9xx series or 1060 and lower, the radeon 5700xt will provide a nice upgrade or if you want nvidia rtx 2070 super is the card to get.
norton
Senior Member
Posts: 194
Senior Member
Posts: 194
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:40 PM
very impressive results, amd made a lot of progress with their GPU and CPU divisions my next CPU will be 3700X
very impressive results, amd made a lot of progress with their GPU and CPU divisions my next CPU will be 3700X
Evildead666
Senior Member
Posts: 1237
Senior Member
Posts: 1237
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:49 PM
5700 at 399€ and XT at 449€ in France (inc Taxes).
Sapphire models In Stock.
5700 at 399€ and XT at 449€ in France (inc Taxes).
Sapphire models In Stock.
Undying
Senior Member
Posts: 11853
Senior Member
Posts: 11853
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:50 PM
This ia better than expected. Amd improved on all areas. 5700xt is up there with 2070S/2080 for 399$.
This ia better than expected. Amd improved on all areas. 5700xt is up there with 2070S/2080 for 399$.
Ryu5uzaku
Senior Member
Posts: 6771
Senior Member
Posts: 6771
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:50 PM
5700 XT seems like a great buy actually. It's doing some weird stuff tho
like BF5 holy what. But still gives solid performance vs lets say Vega 64 in every title 1440p
5700 XT seems like a great buy actually. It's doing some weird stuff tho
like BF5 holy what. But still gives solid performance vs lets say Vega 64 in every title 1440p
OnnA
Senior Member
Posts: 9686
Senior Member
Posts: 9686
Posted on: 07/07/2019 02:56 PM
GJ ATI/AMD
THX for review HH.
GJ ATI/AMD
THX for review HH.
anticupidon
Senior Member
Posts: 4025
Senior Member
Posts: 4025
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:00 PM
Will wait for custom AIB models, noise is a big deal for me
Will wait for custom AIB models, noise is a big deal for me
Undying
Senior Member
Posts: 11853
Senior Member
Posts: 11853
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:02 PM
This gives me hope. 5800/5900xt can actually challange or beat 2080ti. No wonder nvidia is already preparing ampere.
This gives me hope. 5800/5900xt can actually challange or beat 2080ti. No wonder nvidia is already preparing ampere.
Kaleid
Senior Member
Posts: 2372
Senior Member
Posts: 2372
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:05 PM
5700 sounds like a possible upgrade, I don't quite care yet for raytracing, only that the prices are going down somewhat.
5700 sounds like a possible upgrade, I don't quite care yet for raytracing, only that the prices are going down somewhat.
Texter
Senior Member
Posts: 2950
Senior Member
Posts: 2950
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:10 PM
Definitely better than expected...even though these cards are noisy, competitive performance is there on launch day. nVidia really do need the new Supers out there...
Definitely better than expected...even though these cards are noisy, competitive performance is there on launch day. nVidia really do need the new Supers out there...
Jagman
Senior Member
Posts: 2220
Senior Member
Posts: 2220
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:16 PM
WOW! Definitely better than I expected, 5700XT is looking very tempting, bank account is getting nervous
WOW! Definitely better than I expected, 5700XT is looking very tempting, bank account is getting nervous
Aura89
Senior Member
Posts: 7676
Senior Member
Posts: 7676
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:23 PM
Just need Navi 20 and there may be competition in the high end for once in the last while.
Just need Navi 20 and there may be competition in the high end for once in the last while.
sverek
Senior Member
Posts: 5368
Senior Member
Posts: 5368
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:26 PM
5700xt seems like a better pick for same price as RTX2060 super.
Not sure if RTX2070 super is $100 better than 5700xt
5700xt seems like a better pick for same price as RTX2060 super.
Not sure if RTX2070 super is $100 better than 5700xt
Vananovion
Member
Posts: 81
Member
Posts: 81
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:34 PM
The architecture looks promising but it is not quite there yet. I'm gonna wait for 2nd gen/bigger dies - maybe even with HBM2.
The architecture looks promising but it is not quite there yet. I'm gonna wait for 2nd gen/bigger dies - maybe even with HBM2.
karma777police
Senior Member
Posts: 103
Senior Member
Posts: 103
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:36 PM
This product looks better than Zen 2.
This product looks better than Zen 2.
schmidtbag
Senior Member
Posts: 4506
Senior Member
Posts: 4506
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:41 PM
Seems to overall have the same performance-per-watt as the 2070 Super and 2060 Super respectively. Considering the cloud of pessimism surrounding PPW, I'd say that's pretty good. Of course, it'd be nice if it were a little bit better, but this is a nice step in the right direction.
I'm still not going to buy these, not yet anyway. I'd like to see if driver updates help, or maybe wait until 2nd gen rDNA.
Seems to overall have the same performance-per-watt as the 2070 Super and 2060 Super respectively. Considering the cloud of pessimism surrounding PPW, I'd say that's pretty good. Of course, it'd be nice if it were a little bit better, but this is a nice step in the right direction.
I'm still not going to buy these, not yet anyway. I'd like to see if driver updates help, or maybe wait until 2nd gen rDNA.
Andy Watson
Senior Member
Posts: 101
Senior Member
Posts: 101
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:41 PM
Not bad at all. Now need to see about 3rd party proper coolers, getting overclocking sorted out and how much extra they can get out of driver maturation with this new archtecture.
And prices of course in a month or two.
Competitive though, no wonder nvidia had to do something .....
Bring it on
As an aside I can prices in the UK, but nvidia super tend still not to be listed, what is going on there?
Not bad at all. Now need to see about 3rd party proper coolers, getting overclocking sorted out and how much extra they can get out of driver maturation with this new archtecture.
And prices of course in a month or two.
Competitive though, no wonder nvidia had to do something .....
Bring it on
As an aside I can prices in the UK, but nvidia super tend still not to be listed, what is going on there?
Morax
Member
Posts: 79
Member
Posts: 79
Posted on: 07/07/2019 03:55 PM
Better than I expected, I'm actually really curious how the RX 5900 is going to perform in regards to this!
It's a shame it isn't tested with a Zen 2/PCIe 4.0 setup though...
Better than I expected, I'm actually really curious how the RX 5900 is going to perform in regards to this!
It's a shame it isn't tested with a Zen 2/PCIe 4.0 setup though...
alanm
Senior Member
Posts: 8940
Senior Member
Posts: 8940
Posted on: 07/07/2019 04:05 PM
Thanks, nice review. Seems Hilbert got a cooler 5700xt sample than other reviewers. TomsH: high 80s, Compterbase.de: 85c, Techpowerup: 92c!
Thanks, nice review. Seems Hilbert got a cooler 5700xt sample than other reviewers. TomsH: high 80s, Compterbase.de: 85c, Techpowerup: 92c!
Mesab67
Senior Member
Posts: 139
Senior Member
Posts: 139
Posted on: 07/07/2019 04:07 PM
Thanks for the great review Hilbert.
Excellent advances by AMD on the gfx side also. Nice! My 1080 is still doing fine by comparison so I'll wait till next round. However, I'm fully on board with Zen2 as a replacement for my X99 base.
Thanks for the great review Hilbert.
Excellent advances by AMD on the gfx side also. Nice! My 1080 is still doing fine by comparison so I'll wait till next round. However, I'm fully on board with Zen2 as a replacement for my X99 base.
Fox2232
Senior Member
Posts: 9755
Senior Member
Posts: 9755
Posted on: 07/07/2019 04:08 PM
Seems to overall have the same performance-per-watt as the 2070 Super and 2060 Super respectively. Considering the cloud of pessimism surrounding PPW, I'd say that's pretty good. Of course, it'd be nice if it were a little bit better, but this is a nice step in the right direction.
I'm still not going to buy these, not yet anyway. I'd like to see if driver updates help, or maybe wait until 2nd gen rDNA.
XT practically doubles my performance on 1080p, that's very welcome. Would love to pay today for RDNA2 too just because I have certain expectations. But this will do.
Better than I expected, I'm actually really curious how the RX 5900 is going to perform in regards to this!
It's a shame it isn't tested with a Zen 2/PCIe 4.0 setup though...
I think that PCIe 4.0 is no big deal for games. But would be interesting to at last see intel + 3700X on CPU side of test and 5700XT + RTX 2080 Ti on GPU side.
Those components would create 4 results than can be organized into nice matrix. And maybe do just 3~4 games, to not do that many tests.
Even while results may prove to be uneventful.
Seems to overall have the same performance-per-watt as the 2070 Super and 2060 Super respectively. Considering the cloud of pessimism surrounding PPW, I'd say that's pretty good. Of course, it'd be nice if it were a little bit better, but this is a nice step in the right direction.
I'm still not going to buy these, not yet anyway. I'd like to see if driver updates help, or maybe wait until 2nd gen rDNA.
XT practically doubles my performance on 1080p, that's very welcome. Would love to pay today for RDNA2 too just because I have certain expectations. But this will do.
Better than I expected, I'm actually really curious how the RX 5900 is going to perform in regards to this!
It's a shame it isn't tested with a Zen 2/PCIe 4.0 setup though...
I think that PCIe 4.0 is no big deal for games. But would be interesting to at last see intel + 3700X on CPU side of test and 5700XT + RTX 2080 Ti on GPU side.
Those components would create 4 results than can be organized into nice matrix. And maybe do just 3~4 games, to not do that many tests.
Even while results may prove to be uneventful.
pages 1 2 3 4 > »
Click here to post a comment for this article on the message forum.
Senior Member
Posts: 13195
not bad