Intel Skylake processors crash at specific Prime number calculations
Click here to post a comment for Intel Skylake processors crash at specific Prime number calculations on our message forum
Fox2232
As much as AMD Phenom bug. Nearly impossible to happen, normal users did not have to care, and yet BIOS fix was issued. And in process it degraded performance a bit.
GeniusPr0
Octopuss
How can this be fixed with a BIOS update, when apparently something is done wrong on the hardware level (like, some messed up instructions or something)?
Undying
Kaarme
Denial
Warrax
FerCam™
So this is the new 586 aka Pentium?
nexxusting
Neo Cyrus
For most users this means nothing unless an updated BIOS to work around this causes a performance hit like with the Phenoms. For those who are doing intense calculations, a defect like this could be a real problem.
Reminds me of the Pentium FDIV bug, which resulted in some calculations being wrong.
Razoola
Could get real messy if intel also cripple the overclock hack in the same fix
haz_mat
Some things can be fixed in BIOS, happens all the time in fact (as mentioned, errata is not uncommon). I think its too early to tell if there will be a performance hit from the fix, but that is certainly possible.
This particular issue is different than the infamous FDIV bug - there was no system hang there, instead it was yielding incorrect computation when dividing floats.
In that link to the intel forums they mention the issue is only reproducible when hyperthreading is used with AVX instructions on a skylake chip - and they're able to trigger it when computing on a specific large-exponent. A very specific set of conditions to say the least.
From this alone, there is no reason to conclude that this issue is only able to be triggered under these exact circumstances. Someone in that thread even mentioned an ongoing discussion at tomshardware about skylake systems freezing up while idle for no reason, even after RMA'ing multiple components.
I'm sure more information about the issue will be revealed after they have a fix ready, as disclosing too much at this stage is a definite security risk.
WareTernal
So your insane OC may be stable after all?
"There's also FPGAs and other ICs" - that's interesting...What the last Intel CPU that was field programmable?
EspHack
framesx2x
Seriously people there is no way that you cloud fix this, This is IC level problem. A Microcode bios can’t fix or reprogram a processor, which is impossible do in a user level. the only way to fix this, Intel need to do a recall on these processor i7-6700k OR being to start reimbursing everyone who has this processor in hand. it sounds more like they made a mistake with the transistors layout.
Neo Cyrus
Denial
http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/specification-updates/desktop-6th-gen-core-family-spec-update.pdf
Skylake has 53 known errata issues, 54 if you count this one. Haswell had 108:
http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/specification-updates/5th-gen-core-family-spec-update.pdf
I'm sure they'll end up finding more as Skylake matures. But regardless Intel says it has a fix. Yeah sure, if the Fix ends up crippling Skylake performance by a huge amount then Intel should recall the processor. But there is zero indication of that being the case.
You work around the bug. It's done every single processor generation.
Loobyluggs
That's binary for you. Everysoften someone tries to divide by zero, or calculate how many prime numbers there are.
Silly billy's
rflair
Moderator
What prime does it fail on 2 or 3?
dwiewolverine
stick with '-E' system..never doubt it:)