Lexar SL100 Pro Portable SSD 500 GB review
ASUS ROG Maximus XII Hero review
Intel Core i9-10900K processor review
Intel Core i5-10600K processor review
ASRock Z490 Taichi review
ASUS ROG Maximus XII Extreme review
MSI MEG Z490 ACE review
Z490 Aorus Master review
G.Skill TridentZ NEO DDR4 3600 MHz (2x32GB) review
Elgato Key Light Air review
Corsair H100i RGB Pro XT liquid cooler review
Posted by: on: 01/06/2020 08:10 PM [
13 comment(s) ]
Today, we are reviewing an AIO cooler from Corsair: the H100i RGB PRO XT. It’s a new revision of a product that’s been available on the market for quite some time, the H100i Pro.
Read article
Advertisement
Tagged as:
Corsair
pages 1 2 3
Viliu Olariu
Junior Member
Posts: 6
Junior Member
Posts: 6
Posted on: 01/06/2020 09:22 PM
Great review. This makes me happy with my decision of getting noctua nh-d15s. I am a custom builder since mid 90's and i have built prly in thousands of pc's from fully water cooled to passive builds, and i always found that AIO's are way more expensive and less reliable compared to air coolers with minimum perf gain , none at all or even worse .. I can understand that ppl go for looks or sometimes space is a problem, but if you really want water cooling , you should go with full proper cooling with reservoir, pump etc... carefully choosing the parts and design the system
Great review. This makes me happy with my decision of getting noctua nh-d15s. I am a custom builder since mid 90's and i have built prly in thousands of pc's from fully water cooled to passive builds, and i always found that AIO's are way more expensive and less reliable compared to air coolers with minimum perf gain , none at all or even worse .. I can understand that ppl go for looks or sometimes space is a problem, but if you really want water cooling , you should go with full proper cooling with reservoir, pump etc... carefully choosing the parts and design the system
kakiharaFRS
Senior Member
Posts: 339
Senior Member
Posts: 339
Posted on: 01/07/2020 01:32 AM
- with powerful videocards like 1080 or 2080 the backplate is around 80°C and easily up to 100°C with demanding games like borderlands 3 in ultra and this is right under your cpu and memory.... when your gpu is exhausting around 300Watts in your case like my 1080Ti the videocard is cooking everything inside your case, it becomes an oven, an AIO won't fix that but it allows you to suck fresh air from outside of the case so that's a start
- AIOs have limits....my H150i pro and H115ipro rgb platinum where fine for a 5.1Ghz 9900k (to compare with guru3d at 5.0 all cores I had 75-80°C) but for a 3960x TR forget it, with a 9900k I never felt the heat exchanger frame get hot, with TR even at idle it is, my H115i pro is pumping out hot air almost immediately and the water temp is in the 32 at idle and 38°C under load (+5-10°C compared to my 9900k) the H150i pro fails I repasted and re-set it 3x same outcome I would have "okay-ish" water temps but big 100°C+ spikes (keep in mind it was never intended for TR the block is too small and the way to attach it probably isnt stiff enough also the pump is slower than the H115i with default settings), the H115i I can run 100% cpu for 6hrs (did that) and it stay around 90°C which is ok, except...to do that I have to run max fans which is noisy....so I'm going custom water cooling for a better noise/temp ratio which brings me to the next point
- most TR4 air coolers are rated 250W TDP well that's not enough....my 24 cores already outputs 268+Watts stock no overclock at max usage I can't imagine what a 48 or 64 will emit but it's probably the end of generic air-cooling and AIOs for them I tried a Noctua and Bequiet TR4 on my 3960x both worked "ok" but still not as good noise/temp wise as an AIO or custom WC also 100% more annoying to unmount/mount if you want to change TIM etc...I will probably never mount one ever again
p.s.
on the review pictures you can see why if you go for pure looks (which is the only way to go at rgb) I recommended you go with corsair LL fans, LL have a smoother light spread you still see the light sources but only if you really look for it, on QLs bright and dark spots is all you will see, they worked as good as the LL and you have the advantage or turning them in whatever side you need but still not looking as good
Btw what's with the ultra weird fan setup ? you have the front using case air to cool the cpu and exhausting at the front, top fans blowing air inside fighting hot air from the gpu and the rear fan basically sucking any cold air your top fan was bringing down directly out...strange
- with powerful videocards like 1080 or 2080 the backplate is around 80°C and easily up to 100°C with demanding games like borderlands 3 in ultra and this is right under your cpu and memory.... when your gpu is exhausting around 300Watts in your case like my 1080Ti the videocard is cooking everything inside your case, it becomes an oven, an AIO won't fix that but it allows you to suck fresh air from outside of the case so that's a start
- AIOs have limits....my H150i pro and H115ipro rgb platinum where fine for a 5.1Ghz 9900k (to compare with guru3d at 5.0 all cores I had 75-80°C) but for a 3960x TR forget it, with a 9900k I never felt the heat exchanger frame get hot, with TR even at idle it is, my H115i pro is pumping out hot air almost immediately and the water temp is in the 32 at idle and 38°C under load (+5-10°C compared to my 9900k) the H150i pro fails I repasted and re-set it 3x same outcome I would have "okay-ish" water temps but big 100°C+ spikes (keep in mind it was never intended for TR the block is too small and the way to attach it probably isnt stiff enough also the pump is slower than the H115i with default settings), the H115i I can run 100% cpu for 6hrs (did that) and it stay around 90°C which is ok, except...to do that I have to run max fans which is noisy....so I'm going custom water cooling for a better noise/temp ratio which brings me to the next point
- most TR4 air coolers are rated 250W TDP well that's not enough....my 24 cores already outputs 268+Watts stock no overclock at max usage I can't imagine what a 48 or 64 will emit but it's probably the end of generic air-cooling and AIOs for them I tried a Noctua and Bequiet TR4 on my 3960x both worked "ok" but still not as good noise/temp wise as an AIO or custom WC also 100% more annoying to unmount/mount if you want to change TIM etc...I will probably never mount one ever again
p.s.
on the review pictures you can see why if you go for pure looks (which is the only way to go at rgb) I recommended you go with corsair LL fans, LL have a smoother light spread you still see the light sources but only if you really look for it, on QLs bright and dark spots is all you will see, they worked as good as the LL and you have the advantage or turning them in whatever side you need but still not looking as good
Btw what's with the ultra weird fan setup ? you have the front using case air to cool the cpu and exhausting at the front, top fans blowing air inside fighting hot air from the gpu and the rear fan basically sucking any cold air your top fan was bringing down directly out...strange
sykozis
Senior Member
Posts: 21546
Senior Member
Posts: 21546
Posted on: 01/07/2020 03:13 AM
I just rebuilt my old i5 6600K for my son to use. It's actually running cooler (10C+) with a proper HSF (Freezer 33 eSports ONE) than it did under a custom loop.... plus, you can't hear the fan on the HSF at all...unlike these AIO units that are typically noisy.
Great review. This makes me happy with my decision of getting noctua nh-d15s. I am a custom builder since mid 90's and i have built prly in thousands of pc's from fully water cooled to passive builds, and i always found that AIO's are way more expensive and less reliable compared to air coolers with minimum perf gain , none at all or even worse .. I can understand that ppl go for looks or sometimes space is a problem, but if you really want water cooling , you should go with full proper cooling with reservoir, pump etc... carefully choosing the parts and design the system
I just rebuilt my old i5 6600K for my son to use. It's actually running cooler (10C+) with a proper HSF (Freezer 33 eSports ONE) than it did under a custom loop.... plus, you can't hear the fan on the HSF at all...unlike these AIO units that are typically noisy.
Order_66
Senior Member
Posts: 214
Senior Member
Posts: 214
Posted on: 01/07/2020 03:56 AM
I also went with the same Noctua, I tried the AIO thing 3 times and always ended up with pump failure after 12-14 months so I hung it up and went with the best rated air cooler and have no complaints.
Great review. This makes me happy with my decision of getting noctua nh-d15s.
I also went with the same Noctua, I tried the AIO thing 3 times and always ended up with pump failure after 12-14 months so I hung it up and went with the best rated air cooler and have no complaints.
pages 1 2 3
Click here to post a comment for this article on the message forum.
Senior Member
Posts: 197
Great review as always, would have really liked to have the current H100i RGB Platinum to see what the difference is. Pump has the same amount of LEDs and it uses the same fans. The new PRO XT shows as slightly cheaper though.