Review: MSI GeForce RTX 2080 Ti DUKE (is this Duke the new King?)

Published by

Click here to post a comment for Review: MSI GeForce RTX 2080 Ti DUKE (is this Duke the new King?) on our message forum
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/242/242573.jpg
Pimpiklem:

Worries me. all we will here now is this RTX gameworks feature empowering Nvidia to push their agenda and gamers who are pushing it forward are the people who will be suffering from the fall out of its implementation into games. Problem isnt the tech problem is the hidden agenda to cripple performance for competitors creating fake results. It feels like a mixed bag of good and bad whith anything nvidia does.
The problem with AMD is they don't spend the time with enough developers working on optimizations at the end of development. In contrast, nVidia goes out of their way to help developers get their games running as best they can prior to release. Nobody is stopping AMD from doing the same.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/242/242471.jpg
Imo that asus strix is still the king, at least when it comes to thermals.
data/avatar/default/avatar15.webp
Andrew LB:

The problem with AMD is they don't spend the time with enough developers working on optimizations at the end of development. In contrast, nVidia goes out of their way to help developers get their games running as best they can prior to release. Nobody is stopping AMD from doing the same.
yeah thats why Wolflenstein performs so poorly. Mate every game AMD works on performs amazing there is no hidden code to cripple performance and you say that about AMD that just isnt true at all. take it back you know what you said was bs.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/16/16662.jpg
Administrator
Pimpiklem:

Mate every game AMD works on performs amazing there is no hidden code to cripple performance and you say that about AMD that just isnt true at all. take it back you know what you said was bs.
You seriously will need to change your tone on these forums if you would like to remain part of this community.
data/avatar/default/avatar13.webp
I pre-ordered the Duke Ti in August when if first popped up for sale, purely because it looked the best imo. I'm very satisfied after seeing it here as the top performer. 😱
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/216/216349.jpg
JGF:

Hi Hilbert, With all the extensive power draw testing you did, all at the wall apparently, did any of your 2080Ti *systems* exceed 500 watts at the wall? Or approach even? Reason I ask is I have a high quality 550W Seasonic Gold PS supply with a non overclocked 4790K cpu and a non overclocked 980GTX. This system consumes at most a little over 300 watts at the wall even though at the time it was recommended the system have a 450 watt power supply. I'm real curious if I could still use the existing system with a 2080Ti. Sure they recommend a 650W supply but I'm not sure I believe that thats neccessary given my current systems draw (ie is the 2080Ti really going to draw 200 watts more than a 980GTX)... again not an overclocker at all but a happy gamer. Rest of system is just 16gig ram and 3 SSD's. The online power supply estimators estimate my system with a Titan V at around 475 watts so that's still 75 watts of headroom at full load I figure. Thoughts?
Like other members have already wrote, your PSU is too close to the limits and it´s better not to push your luck specially if you are thinking about paying more than 1000€ for a GPU. If you really want the card then buy a new PSU with 700 or 800w to be sure you can use your system without a care and overclock it if you want to.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
tensai28:

So 650w is fine if you want to OC the card? I'm on a SeaSonic S12G 650W.
If your total system's power consumption during synthetic benchmarks reach 500W, then yes, a 650W will suffice. You're still pushing it real hard but at least it'll be stable. I would agree with H83; if you intend to OC, 700-800W is a better choice.
data/avatar/default/avatar12.webp
Hilbert Hagedoorn:

You seriously will need to change your tone on these forums if you would like to remain part of this community.
I know replying to you will get me banned but that's fine opportunity to rare to miss. Truth hurts hey hilbert and the fact you found it necessary to respond to my tiny little comment proves the existence of the Nvidia agenda. Thank you for verifying who your patrons are. see you on twitter with a nice screen grab.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
Pimpiklem:

I know replying to you will get me banned but that's fine opportunity to rare to miss. Truth hurts hey hilbert and the fact you found it necessary to respond to my tiny little comment proves the existence of the Nvidia agenda. Thank you for verifying who your patrons are.
The only Nvidia agenda in any of the discussions lately is coming from you... You're being needlessly antagonistic. What Hilbert wants is for you to stop being such an obvious troll. He doesn't care if you prefer or promote Nvidia, he just doesn't want you insulting people's opinions, which is a perfectly fair thing to ask.
data/avatar/default/avatar04.webp
no point replying to me now mate. my accounts now gone soon because i gave my opinion that wasn't no more needlessly antagonistic than the guy who gave his opinion to mine. But my opinion upset some people, dont see them speaking out when people attack amd do you. funny that is.yeah what ever. anyways nice chatting i be banned soon and thats fine, its only strengthens my screen capture.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/274/274577.jpg
when does rtx 2070 get release ??
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/243/243702.jpg
Pimpiklem:

I know replying to you will get me banned but that's fine opportunity to rare to miss. Truth hurts hey hilbert and the fact you found it necessary to respond to my tiny little comment proves the existence of the Nvidia agenda. Thank you for verifying who your patrons are. see you on twitter with a nice screen grab.
You know what? As much I dislike nVidia. Hilbert is not pushing you some hidden agenda. Nor open agenda.
Andrew LB:

The problem with AMD is they don't spend the time with enough developers working on optimizations at the end of development.
... ...to which you reacted kind of inappropriately means something else than you think. It is not about poor work done with developers. But it is about poor rate at which AMD engages with developers. Yes, AMD has a lot of open source code available. You can probably build pretty solid engine around that. But nVidia is actively seeking developers and that's how they get good/bad features into games. But they get those features and optimizations into games. (There are many cases when nVidia "helped" with new feature to point game would not even start on AMD's GPU. But that's developers responsibility to fix by separate code path or not accept nVidia's code at all.) AMD does marvelous job, that's when they are doing it. And here is source of issue.
data/avatar/default/avatar26.webp
schmidtbag:

The only Nvidia agenda in any of the discussions lately is coming from you... You're being needlessly antagonistic. What Hilbert wants is for you to stop being such an obvious troll. He doesn't care if you prefer or promote Nvidia, he just doesn't want you insulting people's opinions, which is a perfectly fair thing to ask.
Just because he said take it back that makes him antagonistic? How is take it back offensive? Not like he attacked him or anything, he should've formulated that a bit softer so he doesn't upset the sensitive ones. If you can't take a bit of contradiction on a discussion forum then you should stay out of it.
data/avatar/default/avatar37.webp
george1976:

Just because he said take it back that makes him antagonistic? How is take it back offensive? Not like he attacked him or anything, he should've formulated that a bit softer so he doesn't upset the sensitive ones. If you can't take a bit of contradiction on a discussion forum then you should stay out of it.
instead of offering proofs and a solid argument he decided to take the path most traveled and be a troll.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
george1976:

Just because he said take it back that makes him antagonistic? How is take it back offensive? Not like he attacked him or anything, he should've formulated that a bit softer so he doesn't upset the sensitive ones. If you can't take a bit of contradiction on a discussion forum then you should stay out of it.
I was speaking in general. Look at his other posts and you'll find there's a bit of a pattern.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/79/79740.jpg
I think the RTX cards may have strong pro and dev appeal (for offline rendering, video processing) which may keep their sales strong if gamers do not embrace them as widely as previous gens. Compare the specs to RTX quadros and the 2080ti has better gigarays perf than the twice as expensive RTX 5000.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/243/243189.jpg
You have to chill out buddy. Guru3d is where some of the most balanced arguments exist when it comes to hardware discussion, and HH is a man that, certainly from my experience, balances things very well and gives AMD a fair look at all the products he reviews they put out compared to many other sites online. As pointed out by Fox2232 above, developer choices with regards to implementation of features of particular hardware manufacturers does ultimately boil down to those two parties and no one else. And before you accuse me of bias, I am running a 295x2 and no complaints from my end, and certainly the 'fine wine' approach of increasing relative performance over time has helped the card last well, but it isn't exactly a great traditional marketing strategy when the real beauty of the card is revealed a few years down the line.
data/avatar/default/avatar29.webp
How is duke performing better than trio even though trio has better specs?