Fractal Design Vector RS review
Corsair iCUE 465X review
be quiet! Pure Base 500 review
Borderlands 3: PC graphics performance benchmark review
Swiftech H240 X3 AIO review
Promo: URCDKey Autumn Sale Windows 10 Pro for $11
Corsair HS35 Stereo Gaming Headset Review
MSI Radeon RX 5700 XT Gaming X review
Gears of War 5: PC graphics performance benchmark review
XFX Radeon RX 5700 XT THICC II Ultra review
PowerColor 5700 RED DEVIL review
Posted by: on: 08/15/2019 10:01 AM [
47 comment(s) ]
Check the beast, the PowerColor 5700 RED DEVIL that we review today. It has increased clocks, increased looks and well is just customized all the way. Not just that, it is marketed at a retail price of $389,-
Read article
Advertisement
Tagged as:
amd
pages 1 2
Hilbert Hagedoorn
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Posted on: 08/15/2019 10:11 AM
I'll advance on that, this card arrived like yesterday due to all kinds of bad weather in the Taiwan region, and I had been prepping the XT review, and they send the non-XT one. So yes, that was a long day + evening
You do not rest Hilbert, do you?
I'll advance on that, this card arrived like yesterday due to all kinds of bad weather in the Taiwan region, and I had been prepping the XT review, and they send the non-XT one. So yes, that was a long day + evening
Undying
Senior Member
Posts: 11580
Senior Member
Posts: 11580
Posted on: 08/15/2019 10:20 AM
Well we needed one non-xt review beside all that xt's you did this days. Lets hope weather in taiwan will get under control.
I'll advance on that, this card arrived like yesterday due to all kinds of bad weather in the Taiwan region, and I had been prepping the XT review, and they send the non-XT one. So yes, that was a long day + evening
Well we needed one non-xt review beside all that xt's you did this days. Lets hope weather in taiwan will get under control.
Loophole35
Senior Member
Posts: 9308
Senior Member
Posts: 9308
Posted on: 08/15/2019 10:32 AM
I hope the power usage is a typo. This card is using ~50W more than reference 5700 and only about 2% faster. Temps are OK but noise is great.
I hope the power usage is a typo. This card is using ~50W more than reference 5700 and only about 2% faster. Temps are OK but noise is great.
Hilbert Hagedoorn
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Posted on: 08/15/2019 10:37 AM
That is not correct indeed, checking and fixing.
I hope the power usage is a typo. This card is using ~50W more than reference 5700 and only about 2% faster. Temps are OK but noise is great.
That is not correct indeed, checking and fixing.
AlmondMan
Senior Member
Posts: 475
Senior Member
Posts: 475
Posted on: 08/15/2019 11:08 AM
Looks like a great card. Hope it settles a bit in price.
Looks like a great card. Hope it settles a bit in price.
Vananovion
Member
Posts: 78
Member
Posts: 78
Posted on: 08/15/2019 12:38 PM
So basically the same performance as before, just with way better thermals and noise. I'm starting to think that the only reason AMD makes reference cards with a blower style cooler is so that their partners can turn profit.
So basically the same performance as before, just with way better thermals and noise. I'm starting to think that the only reason AMD makes reference cards with a blower style cooler is so that their partners can turn profit.
Embra
Senior Member
Posts: 883
Senior Member
Posts: 883
Posted on: 08/15/2019 12:47 PM
Great review, nice card.
Great review, nice card.
Fox2232
Senior Member
Posts: 9681
Senior Member
Posts: 9681
Posted on: 08/15/2019 02:12 PM
I wonder about XT. But this one is for now best one in terms of temperature to noise. Good Job PowerColor.
Edit: @Hilbert Hagedoorn : Can you add photo showing how/where heatpipes touch that large hotplate?
Are they touching it even above memory chips? That could significantly improve their thermals.
I wonder about XT. But this one is for now best one in terms of temperature to noise. Good Job PowerColor.
Edit: @Hilbert Hagedoorn : Can you add photo showing how/where heatpipes touch that large hotplate?
Are they touching it even above memory chips? That could significantly improve their thermals.
venturi
Senior Member
Posts: 260
Senior Member
Posts: 260
Posted on: 08/15/2019 03:19 PM
The GPU shoot out chart does not include Titan V and Titan RTX. As they are not professional Quadro series cars why are they not included? Titan XP is included.
The GPU shoot out chart does not include Titan V and Titan RTX. As they are not professional Quadro series cars why are they not included? Titan XP is included.
Hilbert Hagedoorn
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Posted on: 08/15/2019 03:24 PM
Have you seen a review on our website on these? Nope, because NVIDIA would not send it out to media.
The GPU shoot out chart does not include Titan V and Titan RTX. As they are not professional Quadro series cars why are they not included?
Have you seen a review on our website on these? Nope, because NVIDIA would not send it out to media.
zero_cool
Member
Posts: 57
Member
Posts: 57
Posted on: 08/15/2019 03:53 PM
Are you on internet explorer? What kind of stupid question is this?
The GPU shoot out chart does not include Titan V and Titan RTX. As they are not professional Quadro series cars why are they not included? Titan XP is included.
Are you on internet explorer? What kind of stupid question is this?
MonstroMart
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Posted on: 08/15/2019 04:20 PM
Why don't you buy one to review it? /sarcasm
Have you seen a review on our website on these? Nope, because NVIDIA would not send it out to media.
Why don't you buy one to review it? /sarcasm
Hilbert Hagedoorn
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Don Vito Corleone
Posts: 35896
Posted on: 08/15/2019 04:47 PM
Why don't you buy one so we can review it? /sarcasm
Why don't you buy one to review it? /sarcasm
Why don't you buy one so we can review it? /sarcasm
MonstroMart
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Posted on: 08/15/2019 04:51 PM
Hilbert Hagedoorn 1 - MonstroMart 0
Why don't you buy one so we can review it? /sarcasm
Hilbert Hagedoorn 1 - MonstroMart 0
Robbo9999
Senior Member
Posts: 1303
Senior Member
Posts: 1303
Posted on: 08/15/2019 06:44 PM
Man, both NVidia & AMD need to start making big boy cards again, just look at this power consumption chart:
https://www.guru3d.com/articles-pages/powercolor-5700-red-devil-review,8.html
You can see that the AMD 295x2 and Titan Z were up at 500W! They need to start offering chips large enough (enough transistors) to consume that amount of power combined with some awesome cooling - now that would be a high end card with some exciting performance...they should do it!
Ok, they were both dual GPU cards, but still that's extra performance, and if they could offer that amount of transistors in one chip then that would be the pinacle - more transistors please!
EDIT: if 500W is the sensible limit for the physical cooling on one card, then I think they should try to fill that - that's max performance for the people!
Man, both NVidia & AMD need to start making big boy cards again, just look at this power consumption chart:
https://www.guru3d.com/articles-pages/powercolor-5700-red-devil-review,8.html
You can see that the AMD 295x2 and Titan Z were up at 500W! They need to start offering chips large enough (enough transistors) to consume that amount of power combined with some awesome cooling - now that would be a high end card with some exciting performance...they should do it!
Ok, they were both dual GPU cards, but still that's extra performance, and if they could offer that amount of transistors in one chip then that would be the pinacle - more transistors please!
EDIT: if 500W is the sensible limit for the physical cooling on one card, then I think they should try to fill that - that's max performance for the people!
MonstroMart
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Posted on: 08/15/2019 07:26 PM
BTW guys i'm looking to buy a 5700XT since it performs just a tiny notch under a 2070 Super and cost significantly less in Canada. Don't try to sell me ray tracing please i just don't think it's worth the premium asked for now i'm just looking to get more fps at 2k without having to spend 700$ CAD.
I never bought PowerColor but it looks like they have the best 5700 so far. Just watched a review for the Red Devil 5700XT on youtube and i like what i see. Nearly silent. Cool enough. Power consumption ain't too bad it's definitely within the acceptable range for me. And well it looks good imo. Anyone bought PowerColor in the past? How are their support and warranty?
BTW guys i'm looking to buy a 5700XT since it performs just a tiny notch under a 2070 Super and cost significantly less in Canada. Don't try to sell me ray tracing please i just don't think it's worth the premium asked for now i'm just looking to get more fps at 2k without having to spend 700$ CAD.
I never bought PowerColor but it looks like they have the best 5700 so far. Just watched a review for the Red Devil 5700XT on youtube and i like what i see. Nearly silent. Cool enough. Power consumption ain't too bad it's definitely within the acceptable range for me. And well it looks good imo. Anyone bought PowerColor in the past? How are their support and warranty?
JaxMacFL
Senior Member
Posts: 1667
Senior Member
Posts: 1667
Posted on: 08/15/2019 07:37 PM
shhssh, either go all out or stay at home.....other wise bias....
shhssh, either go all out or stay at home.....other wise bias....
Elder III
Senior Member
Posts: 3560
Senior Member
Posts: 3560
Posted on: 08/15/2019 07:52 PM
That is a very quiet video card; kicking tail vs all the competition that I've seen so far (referring to acoustics).
BTW guys i'm looking to buy a 5700XT since it performs just a tiny notch under a 2070 Super and cost significantly less in Canada. Don't try to sell me ray tracing please i just don't think it's worth the premium asked for now i'm just looking to get more fps at 2k without having to spend 700$ CAD.
I never bought PowerColor but it looks like they have the best 5700 so far. Just watched a review for the Red Devil 5700XT on youtube and i like what i see. Nearly silent. Cool enough. Power consumption ain't too bad it's definitely within the acceptable range for me. And well it looks good imo. Anyone bought PowerColor in the past? How are their support and warranty?
I have owned several PowerColor GPUs over the past decade and the only time i had to deal with their warranty was over 8 years ago when I had a brand new GPU delivered with a fan that hit the shroud as soon as it was started. They replaced it without any trouble; granted that was a long time ago so I don't know what their support is like now. More recently I did have a Red Devil Rx 480 8GB that had a great cooler on it and ran well for me for over 2 years (I sold it when I upgraded my secondary system to a 4K monitor).
That is a very quiet video card; kicking tail vs all the competition that I've seen so far (referring to acoustics).
BTW guys i'm looking to buy a 5700XT since it performs just a tiny notch under a 2070 Super and cost significantly less in Canada. Don't try to sell me ray tracing please i just don't think it's worth the premium asked for now i'm just looking to get more fps at 2k without having to spend 700$ CAD.
I never bought PowerColor but it looks like they have the best 5700 so far. Just watched a review for the Red Devil 5700XT on youtube and i like what i see. Nearly silent. Cool enough. Power consumption ain't too bad it's definitely within the acceptable range for me. And well it looks good imo. Anyone bought PowerColor in the past? How are their support and warranty?
I have owned several PowerColor GPUs over the past decade and the only time i had to deal with their warranty was over 8 years ago when I had a brand new GPU delivered with a fan that hit the shroud as soon as it was started. They replaced it without any trouble; granted that was a long time ago so I don't know what their support is like now. More recently I did have a Red Devil Rx 480 8GB that had a great cooler on it and ran well for me for over 2 years (I sold it when I upgraded my secondary system to a 4K monitor).
Embra
Senior Member
Posts: 883
Senior Member
Posts: 883
Posted on: 08/15/2019 07:55 PM
BTW guys i'm looking to buy a 5700XT since it performs just a tiny notch under a 2070 Super and cost significantly less in Canada. Don't try to sell me ray tracing please i just don't think it's worth the premium asked for now i'm just looking to get more fps at 2k without having to spend 700$ CAD.
I never bought PowerColor but it looks like they have the best 5700 so far. Just watched a review for the Red Devil 5700XT on youtube and i like what i see. Nearly silent. Cool enough. Power consumption ain't too bad it's definitely within the acceptable range for me. And well it looks good imo. Anyone bought PowerColor in the past? How are their support and warranty?
PowerColor has become much better with there cooling. I personal prefer Sapphire for AMD, they have the best quality and are very consist.
I do think the Powercolor Red Devil line has been good.
BTW guys i'm looking to buy a 5700XT since it performs just a tiny notch under a 2070 Super and cost significantly less in Canada. Don't try to sell me ray tracing please i just don't think it's worth the premium asked for now i'm just looking to get more fps at 2k without having to spend 700$ CAD.
I never bought PowerColor but it looks like they have the best 5700 so far. Just watched a review for the Red Devil 5700XT on youtube and i like what i see. Nearly silent. Cool enough. Power consumption ain't too bad it's definitely within the acceptable range for me. And well it looks good imo. Anyone bought PowerColor in the past? How are their support and warranty?
PowerColor has become much better with there cooling. I personal prefer Sapphire for AMD, they have the best quality and are very consist.
I do think the Powercolor Red Devil line has been good.
ladcrooks
Senior Member
Posts: 282
Senior Member
Posts: 282
Posted on: 08/15/2019 08:49 PM
maybe a nice card but a crappy 2 yr warranty puts me off
maybe a nice card but a crappy 2 yr warranty puts me off
venturi
Senior Member
Posts: 260
Senior Member
Posts: 260
Posted on: 08/15/2019 09:07 PM
Hilbert Hagedoorn 1 - MonstroMart 0
Why don't you buy one so we can review it? /sarcasm
I have 6,
4 are regular Titan V and 2 are 32GB CEO edition.
I am curious because I have been able to use mine for both research (AI/DL/ML in medical imaging), Nuc Med, and normal home stuffm gaming etc.
I am able to do mGPU and 4 Way SLI (auto-diff-SLI) as well as compute/cuda
(I am also the guy that enabled 4 way SLI on the Pascal and RTX series cads and wrote the how-to). My curiosity is based on how rankings are on a comparison. Since the Titan XP was listed, I figured the same class of card from recent releases would be listed.
Seemed a valid question....
Here is my personal rig configured using 4 of the cards
I'll be glad to provide a factual review.
Asus c621e sage
2x Xeon 8180M
768GB of ram LRDIMM
4x Titan V including Titan V CEO ed 32GB
960pro nvme (OS)
10x SSD Raid - 4TB each SSD (Apps and Backup 8x 2x) (40TB)
1600W PSU (digital) noiseless
MS 2019 Data Center, Ubuntu
P1 miniITX case
Hilbert Hagedoorn 1 - MonstroMart 0
Why don't you buy one so we can review it? /sarcasm
I have 6,
4 are regular Titan V and 2 are 32GB CEO edition.
I am curious because I have been able to use mine for both research (AI/DL/ML in medical imaging), Nuc Med, and normal home stuffm gaming etc.
I am able to do mGPU and 4 Way SLI (auto-diff-SLI) as well as compute/cuda
(I am also the guy that enabled 4 way SLI on the Pascal and RTX series cads and wrote the how-to). My curiosity is based on how rankings are on a comparison. Since the Titan XP was listed, I figured the same class of card from recent releases would be listed.
Seemed a valid question....
Here is my personal rig configured using 4 of the cards
I'll be glad to provide a factual review.
Asus c621e sage
2x Xeon 8180M
768GB of ram LRDIMM
4x Titan V including Titan V CEO ed 32GB
960pro nvme (OS)
10x SSD Raid - 4TB each SSD (Apps and Backup 8x 2x) (40TB)
1600W PSU (digital) noiseless
MS 2019 Data Center, Ubuntu
P1 miniITX case
MonstroMart
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Senior Member
Posts: 534
Posted on: 08/15/2019 09:28 PM
That case ... i hope you don't have a cat
You got to realize not everyone have that kind of money at hand for a computer. This workstation is probably in the neighborhood or 40-45 grands in Canada. You're getting dangerously close to the price of a car here ... there's not many use cases for a workstation like that.
If nVidia doesn't send him the gpu to review i don't think there much point for him to buy one to review it considering that probably only a very tiny portion of the people reading his reviews have the money to buy one.
That case ... i hope you don't have a cat
You got to realize not everyone have that kind of money at hand for a computer. This workstation is probably in the neighborhood or 40-45 grands in Canada. You're getting dangerously close to the price of a car here ... there's not many use cases for a workstation like that.
If nVidia doesn't send him the gpu to review i don't think there much point for him to buy one to review it considering that probably only a very tiny portion of the people reading his reviews have the money to buy one.
venturi
Senior Member
Posts: 260
Senior Member
Posts: 260
Posted on: 08/15/2019 10:18 PM
That case ... i hope you don't have a cat
You got to realize not everyone have that kind of money at hand for a computer. This workstation is probably in the neighborhood or 40-45 grands in Canada. You're getting dangerously close to the price of a car here ... there's not many use cases for a workstation like that.
If nVidia doesn't send him the gpu to review i don't think there much point for him to buy one to review it considering that probably only a very tiny portion of the people reading his reviews have the money to buy one.
I can respect that. I also realize that that list (their card shoot out) is populated by source testing and not outside numbers, which also makes sense. I had assumed the Titan Vs were omitted just because of perception as a pro card only (like quadro). Now I know they were not offered a card to test it makes more sense. I am surprised nvidia would not give Titan Vs or RTX to Guru3d for review - I'b be quite vocal if I was this site.
No, I don't have a cat, just 7 and 8 year old kids (might be worse)
That case ... i hope you don't have a cat
You got to realize not everyone have that kind of money at hand for a computer. This workstation is probably in the neighborhood or 40-45 grands in Canada. You're getting dangerously close to the price of a car here ... there's not many use cases for a workstation like that.
If nVidia doesn't send him the gpu to review i don't think there much point for him to buy one to review it considering that probably only a very tiny portion of the people reading his reviews have the money to buy one.
I can respect that. I also realize that that list (their card shoot out) is populated by source testing and not outside numbers, which also makes sense. I had assumed the Titan Vs were omitted just because of perception as a pro card only (like quadro). Now I know they were not offered a card to test it makes more sense. I am surprised nvidia would not give Titan Vs or RTX to Guru3d for review - I'b be quite vocal if I was this site.
No, I don't have a cat, just 7 and 8 year old kids (might be worse)
Robbo9999
Senior Member
Posts: 1303
Senior Member
Posts: 1303
Posted on: 08/15/2019 10:40 PM
I have 6,
4 are regular Titan V and 2 are 32GB CEO edition.
I am curious because I have been able to use mine for both research (AI/DL/ML in medical imaging), Nuc Med, and normal home stuffm gaming etc.
I am able to do mGPU and 4 Way SLI (auto-diff-SLI) as well as compute/cuda
(I am also the guy that enabled 4 way SLI on the Pascal and RTX series cads and wrote the how-to). My curiosity is based on how rankings are on a comparison. Since the Titan XP was listed, I figured the same class of card from recent releases would be listed.
Seemed a valid question....
Here is my personal rig configured using 4 of the cards
I'll be glad to provide a factual review.
Asus c621e sage
2x Xeon 8180M
768GB of ram LRDIMM
4x Titan V including Titan V CEO ed 32GB
960pro nvme (OS)
10x SSD Raid - 4TB each SSD (Apps and Backup 8x 2x)
1600W PSU (digital) noiseless
MS 2019 Data Center, Ubuntu
P1 miniITX case
Wow, overkill, I don't even know the parts that are included in that rig! I suppose you could send your GPUs to Hilbert for review! (bit late in the day now though probably)
I have 6,
4 are regular Titan V and 2 are 32GB CEO edition.
I am curious because I have been able to use mine for both research (AI/DL/ML in medical imaging), Nuc Med, and normal home stuffm gaming etc.
I am able to do mGPU and 4 Way SLI (auto-diff-SLI) as well as compute/cuda
(I am also the guy that enabled 4 way SLI on the Pascal and RTX series cads and wrote the how-to). My curiosity is based on how rankings are on a comparison. Since the Titan XP was listed, I figured the same class of card from recent releases would be listed.
Seemed a valid question....
Here is my personal rig configured using 4 of the cards
I'll be glad to provide a factual review.
Asus c621e sage
2x Xeon 8180M
768GB of ram LRDIMM
4x Titan V including Titan V CEO ed 32GB
960pro nvme (OS)
10x SSD Raid - 4TB each SSD (Apps and Backup 8x 2x)
1600W PSU (digital) noiseless
MS 2019 Data Center, Ubuntu
P1 miniITX case
Wow, overkill, I don't even know the parts that are included in that rig! I suppose you could send your GPUs to Hilbert for review! (bit late in the day now though probably)
pages 1 2
Click here to post a comment for this article on the message forum.
Senior Member
Posts: 11580
Beautiful card. I like the devil redisign and performance seems decent at that price.
You do not rest Hilbert, do you?