Sim City 2013 Launch is one big Sim Failure




Posted by Hilbert Hagedoorn on: 03/07/2013 12:28 PM | 59 comment(s) ]
Last night EA and Maxis launched Sim City 2013 for certain regions, anxious as I am I pre-ordered this game myself back in February. To date I have not received a key (even though EA was very keen to take my pre-order money). Things however are escalating, there are game delays, frustrated end users and server issues as well. Here's the thing, EA did not allow preloading the game, so once it was released their servers simply could not take it anymore. Hence they halted delivering Keys towards their sales partners, they on their end can't distribute the Origin keys to the customers (like me). More after the break.
So here I am sitting, waiting on a key. But then when you load up EA's twitter account ... you'll notice I am not the only one with a problem. The entire launch seems to be one massive failure.
The company stood its ground that there would be no preloading of the game before the launch as their services would prove stable enough, but the assumptions were obviously wrong. Users warned for months that the company should allow preloading but the company consistently said that they believed their services would handle the capacity and demand at launch. They also said that the development team were ”working to polish the game until the very last second.”
Inevitably, as soon as the game actually launched and some users were able to get their keys, the servers slowed to a crawl. If you were lucky enough to actually redeem your key and start the download it would be too slow.
"We are aware of an issue affecting customers trying to download The Digital Deluxe edition of SimCity. We are working to correct this issue," EA said in a tweeted statement overnight. Later, even after the problems were officially "resolved," EA warned that "due to server load it may take up to three hours for your game to unlock.”
The Origin support forums are predictably loaded with complaints about download and login problems. A community manager had to hop on this morning to apologize and explain the process for requesting a refund.
It doesn't stop there though, if you got lucky, got the game and want to play .. there's DRM requiring you to always be online with the game talking to EA's servers. With these pretty much being down .. well you can imaging what's happening there.
Simcity buyers have done the same thing and have taken to Metacritic to voice their disgust about the game, with it already seeing a 3.8 out of 10 rating. Many gamers will remember something identical happening with Diablo 3 last year, another online-only title. EA said that it had learned from the mistakes of that title, but apparently not.
Well, EA. I do hope to at least receive my key by the end of the week as really, is was just the first wave of SimCity's worldwide launch
Wether or not I can download and play the game, well ... to be continued.
Master Guru
Posts: 183
Joined: 2006-05-26
Why pre-order the game? I've never pre-ordered the game and probably never will. When you people learn...
Administrator
Posts: 16979
Joined: 2000-02-22
Several reasons, often its cheaper and more importantly (normally) you can preload the game. So you are good to go once the game goes live.
Especially with a website known for VGA performance reviews that you see within days after the launch, preloading is handy and a time saver.
Ancient Guru
Posts: 5749
Joined: 2008-01-06
Starcraft 2 Heart of the swarm gives you access to their beta if you preorder...
On topic: EA already killed the series for me, that and C&C/RA
Ancient Guru
Posts: 6349
Joined: 2004-05-16
Starcraft 2 Heart of the swarm gives you access to their beta if you preorder...
On topic: EA already killed the series for me, that and C&C/RA
EA always kills everything, and they wonder why their stock is dropping. Perhaps it's because of **** like this. My buddy bought Simcity and has been trying to get me to buy it -- I'll pick it up eventually but it's amusing because all last night he wasn't unable to play it for more than a couple minutes between server outages.
Blizzard on the other hand is actually able to handle the load for the most part.
Ancient Guru
Posts: 5024
Joined: 2004-09-04
Rubbish like this is actually fueling piracy. Why pay for a game, unable to play it on the day of release, have to have a constant connection so you are screwed if you are in an area without internet or travelling when you can:
1) Download it a few days after launch
2) Comes DRM free
3) Can play it anywhere without a constant connection
4) Its free
I gave up after the Empire total war where it took me over a day to download.
I have not bought a PC game since, OTHER than games that are on offer at silly prices on steam sales.
Sorry EA, you screwed up, you screwed your profits and possibly the gaming industry NOT piracy.
/rant
Ancient Guru
Posts: 3434
Joined: 2006-10-11
shame on anyone who bought this
Member Guru
Posts: 45
Joined: 2013-01-03
Putting aside the complaining about DRM and the whole piracy vs legit copy.
I was ridiculously enthusiastic about this game. However in the run up to the game e.g beta testers and so on, I began hearing nothing but negativity towards the gameplay itself.
From an honest point of view (unbiased towards EA) is the game actually any good?
I see official reviews giving good ratings but the majority or user reviews slating the game. My grievance is that many of these reviews are slating it just because of their hatred towards EA.
Ancient Guru
Posts: 3870
Joined: 2005-12-06
I actually really enjoy the game and have had no major problems with it at all. I started the download before I went to work on Tuesday and by the time I got home it was ready for me to play. Got right into a server with no issues.
I've been having quite a good time teaming up with a few friends in my region
Master Guru
Posts: 188
Joined: 2009-08-25
It explains why I can't play yet -.-' Why I'm not even surprised.
Master Guru
Posts: 413
Joined: 2007-04-17
@Hilbert not sure if this is totally true I just got in a email with the below message could it be delaying tactics cos of the issues
Please find below an urgent message regarding your SimCity Limited Edition CD Key.
It has been brought to our attention by our supplier and an EA Origin Official that there is a language issue bug when pre loading SimCity Limited Edition onto your Origin platform. When activating the key within EA Origin you will be notified that the game is only available in certain languages. We have been assured that this is in fact a bug and that the game will be available in whatever language you have your EA Origin set to (we will be testing in English only). An EA Origin Official has notified us that a fix will be released tomorrow (08th March 2013) to rectify this issue.
Due to this issue many suppliers (including ours) are holding their stock back and will not be releasing it until it has been confirmed that the game does in fact include the required language (English). We are expecting to receive our stock between 01:00-03:00 GMT on Friday 08th March 2013 at which point it will be emailed our directly to you.
Sorry for any inconvenience this has caused and please do not hesitate to get In touch should you have any further questions.
Kindest Regards
SimplyGames Customer Service
Maha Guru
Posts: 1194
Joined: 2006-05-18
Yeah sad thing is I hear that Sim City 2013 has already been cracked.
Ancient Guru
Posts: 6349
Joined: 2004-05-16
I doubt that. A very large portion of the game is streamed from EA's servers, which also do cloud based calculations and send them back to the client. It's going to be a while before someone reverse engineers the server. Plus I checked all the sites and places I know and I haven't seen it.
Master Guru
Posts: 704
Joined: 2001-11-12
And now ask yourself why in the world would someone vote EA for the worst company of 2012...
Yeah remind me again pls, because they do not care about their customers which infact is the very definition of a bad company...
Now if you still going to purchase gaming titles from EA... go on, you know
what to expect.
Ancient Guru
Posts: 5886
Joined: 2006-01-18
I've only done it once, ArmA3.
Bohemia is a responsible studio and now they have a great publishing system (Steam) behind them, I have no doubt that ArmA 3 will turn out as expected.

Master Guru
Posts: 637
Joined: 2011-12-04
Not surprised.