PC Buyers Guide Summer 2009 (Page 3)

PC Buyers Guide Summer 2009

PC Buyers Guide 38 Page 3 of 3 Published 2009-07-09 14:00 by David Gunning

Reviews

PC Buyer's Guide - High End

@page {margin: 0.79in; } P { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } H3 { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } A:link { so-language: zxx } @page {margin: 0.79in; } P { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } H3 { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } A:link { so-language: zxx } @page {margin: 0.79in; } P { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } H3 { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } A:link { so-language: zxx } @page {margin: 0.79in; } P { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } H3 { MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0.08in } A:link { so-language: zxx }

Target Monitor Resolution: 1920x1080 to 2560x1600

This guide will only cover the box. Monitor, keyboard, mouse and speakers are not included. I do this for brevity's sake, as the monitor alone would require its own guide, especially if I were to cover LCD monitors. Since this site is called "Guru3D" this guide will target a system intended for gaming primarily. So what sort of criteria do I take into account when deciding what parts to recommend?

Price and Performance: First and foremost, what gives the most bang for your buck, in terms of gaming primarily of course.
Reliability: Second on the list but just as important. This includes things such as compatibility (ever had RAM that worked on one motherboard but not in another?), trustworthiness of a brand overall (do they have a history of making reliable parts?) in addition to the reliability of the part in question.
Overclockability: Overclocking can help squeeze out that extra performance out of a system and can make a big impact on price versus performance (why should you buy a $1000 CPU if you can overclock a $200 CPU to match it?) so this factor can always swing my decision.
Heat and Power Issues: Heat is the enemy of a computer and it can affect the stability (and reliability) of your machine. Performance per watt has become a buzz word and as power requirements for computers rise I eye this more and more closely.

For those wondering about "Target Resolution," instead of listing a particular price point (since price will vary somewhat with vendor/e-tailer) I have listed here what type of resolutions you can expect to be playing most of today's games (with AA and AF on of course) on such a rig, both standard and widescreen resolutions were taken into consideration.

Intel Core i7 NehalemUnfortunately remains Intel standing alone at the high end. The Core i7 brings a number of advancements to the Intel processor including native quad cores, integrated tri-channel memory controller, Hyperthreading and more. For more information check out Guru3D's review. For you overclockers the Core i7 920 is pure gold at under 300 USD.

For the more conservative the 950 is an excellent choice... as for the "Extreme" 975, yeah the only thing extreme is the price, that money is better spent elsewhere on your rig.

Now for a word of warning: Intel has their upcoming Lynnfield processors, intended for the mainstream market based off of the Nehalem core, but with only a dual channel memory controller and in a different socket: LGA-1156. In an even more infuriating move then having multiple sockets to complicate upgrades, Intel has decided to call some of these Lynnfield's Core i7's. So you want to make sure not be confused between an Intel Core i7 LGA-1366 (Nehalem) and Intel Core i7 LGA-1156 (Lynnfield).

Check out Guru3D related reviews:

Noctua NH-U12P SE1366Note that heatsinks made for Socket 775 will not fit the new Socket 1366 (nor the upcoming Socket 1156) without an adapter. Fortunately many manufacturers are starting to make those available and a line of new coolers have now made their way onto the market for the Core i7. Here is a monster of a cooler for your CPU (and I do mean monster, make sure your case and motherboard will support this beast) that will offer hands down some of the best and quietest air cooling available for your processor. It also has one of the best mounting systems it has been my pleasure to work with.

What to look for when buying a motherboard, regardless of chipset or processor it supports:

Good chipset cooling. Chipsets these days continue to run hotter. Better cooling means improved stability, improved longevity and better overclocking potential. Be mindful when using a passively cooled motherboard (even one with the works, including copper heatsinks and heatpipes) to ensure that you can provide the coolers with adequate airflow.
Solid state capacitors. Offers improved longevity and heat resistance as well as avoids the dreaded "leaking" capacitor problem.
Improved voltage regulator. Does the motherboard use a 3 phase voltage regulator or something higher? How do you determine the phase you ask? It is determined by the number of MOSFETs (Metal Oxide Semiconductor Field Effect Transistor) used. As a rule the higher the number (and hence the phase) and quality of the MOSFETs, the cleaner (higher quality) the voltage delivered to the CPU, offering improved stability and overclockability of the CPU and improved thermals for the MOSFETs. Many motherboards now feature heatsinks to cool the MOSFETs as well, always nice.
Features. What features do you need? Chipset features vary broadly as do features individual motherboards may offer. Do you need RAID? If so what type? If you chose to use onboard sound then take a close look at the audio chipset and its associated features as they differ widely. All things to consider.

Editor's Choice: For the new Core i7 there is only one chipset available: Intel's X58. An update to the X48, it boasts one feature that every enthusiast has been pining for: support for both AMD Crossfire and NVIDIA SLI. Note that not every X58 motherboard will support SLI as initially it required the motherboard manufacturer to submit the motherboard to NVIDIA for certification. The price on the motherboards has started to fall mercifully and there are a number of boards to be found for under the 200 USD mark now.

Check out Guru3D related reviews:

300 GB Western Digital VelociRaptor
A high end computer deserves a high end drive. Western Digital's update to their well known 10,000 RPM Raptor hard drive is quite a change. The interface has been updated to 3.0 Gb/s SATA and the capacity has been doubled. However the most dramatic change was switching to a 2.5" design normally reserved to laptops and housing the drive in a heatsink to fit the standard 3.5" design, which allows this drive to be one of the coolest, quietest and most power efficient desktop hard drive on the market.

Alright what about Solid State Disks you ask? Short answer: wait for Windows 7. Now for those of you still reading here's the long answer. SSD's are still in their infancy and are having some growing pains. First capacities remain small and price extremely high compared to traditional hard drives. OS aren't yet optimized for SSD's, one of the most important things Windows 7 will bring is TRIM support, which should help with SSD's problem of degrading performance over time (which can right now only fully be restored with a rather archaic secure format of the drive). Early memory controller suffered performance issues in real world performance (such as stuttering), now we are beginning to see better controllers reach the market but the firmware updates are still fast and furious. A little more patience will mean a cheaper SSD and better performance.

But since this is the turning point for SSD storage units, should you opt an SSD, read one of our many many reviews and focus on the SSDs with Indilinx and Samsung controllers, read more here.

Editor's Note: While I give my recommendation with only a single drive in mind there are many configurations available. Here's a list:

For fastest load times: 2 smaller drives in RAID 0. Drawback: reliability, if one drive fails, the data on both is lost.
For data reliability: 2 large drives in RAID 1. Drawback: capacity halved (all the data on one drive is mirrored on the second).
For heavy downloader's: One small, fast primary drive (like a Western Digital Raptor) for Windows and applications/games and a secondary large capacity drive for downloads/multimedia (such as HD video). This is actually my preferred configuration.

6 GB DDR3 1600 MHz RAMSix GB seems like an odd number doesn't it? Well with the Nehalem's tri-channel memory controller you want to install RAM in three's instead of pairs for optimum performance. Now there are a lot of DDR3 modules available on the market but Intel has included one very large caveat with their Core i7 processors: that the memory voltage not exceed 1.65 volts if you wish to avoid premature processor death. So unless you are feeling particularly adventurous, you will want to be on the lookout for tri-memory kits made specifically for the Core i7. Also note that to use that 6 GB you're gonna need to install a 64 bit version of your OS of choice.

Check out Guru3D related reviews:

GeForce GTX 275 SLI or Radeon 4890 CrossFireTo be honest personally I am not a huge fan of multi-GPU setups. It means much more power, much higher cost, more driver problems and well ... not every game scales well with multiple GPU's. However if you want the highest gaming performance today that's what you'll be getting. Both of these solutions come in at around the same price and both will chew through any game you want to play.

Whether you are an NVIDIA or AMD fan, you've got to love the competition between the two, video card prices have taken quite a tumble. April brought two new cards to the field to battle one another, the GeForce GTX 275 and Radeon 4890. The GeForce GTX 275 is based on the same 55nm GPU as its faster predecessor, the GTX 285, with the full 240 shaders while retaining the memory configuration of the card it replaces in this guide, the GTX 260. The AMD Radeon 4890 represents a refresh of their already excellent 4870, boasting higher clock and memory speeds. You will not be disappointed with either choice of card.

For those wondering why I did not recommend a three or quad GPU setup, unfortunately multi-GPU does not scale well past two GPU's, meaning you get very little extra performance for a shockingly high price. And let's not mention the power such a setup will use.

Why not a GTX 295 you ask ? Well a GTX 295 is basically 2x GTX 275. And 2x GTX 275 = cheaper to purchase than one GTX 295. You do need a SLI compatible motherboard, though at this level we assume you have a X58 motherboards anyway.

Check out Guru3D related reviews:

Asus Xonar D2X 7.1
Vista has left the audio card market wide open by removing direct hardware access, thus taking away Creative's long enjoyed performance advantage thanks to EAX. Into the fray comes Asus with an excellent card that offers a knock out punch:

Our own audiophile Brann Mitchel: Speaking of fearsome, it took all of 5 seconds of listening to the Xonar D2X to know that it is our new reference sound card. This unseats the Auzentech X-Fi Prelude at the high end (not that we really keep track of these things) as our favorite all-around card to game, listen to music, and watch movies with.

Check out Guru3D related reviews:

Asus Xonar D2X Sound Card

Samsung Lightscribe DVD Burner SH-223QThere really is no excuse to not have DVD±R/RW drives, they are very cheap and reliable these days. This drive is capable of burning 22x DVD+R and DVD-R, 16x DL as well as 12x DVD-RAM and boasts a SATA interface. It is also a LightScribe capable drive. This will allow you to burn a label (or image or whatever you want) onto your disks, no more barely legible permanent marker labeling!

Now for those of you with a little extra cash, it's time to start thinking about a Blu-ray drive. The LG GGC-H20L is a good, affordable choice. It supports Blu-ray, HD-DVD (for all you foolish early adopters), DVD and CD burning and LightScribe support.

Okay Im going leave this one open to your decision. Cases are a love-hate thing, what one person likes another will not. So go find a case you think suites you. I have a few suggestions when looking for a case. Aluminum is a definite plus; it will make your computer significantly lighter. 120mm fans are the way to go as well, ensuring good airflow in your case while maintaining a minimum of noise. A removable motherboard tray is particularly useful in cramped cases.

Check out Guru3D related reviews:

Lian Li PC-V1000 Plus Aluminum Case

1000 Watts or HigherThe power demands of the PC continue to escalate, thanks in large part to GPU's and the move to quad core CPU's. Be sure to go out and get the biggest and best power supply you can, do not skimp on the power supply! This is an often overlooked part and yet it's the source of so many computer woes. Be sure to check the amps on the 12V rail(s), you want a power supply that can handle a lot, multiple 12V rails is an additional plus (although not required, PC Power and Cooling is well known for their excellent single 12V rail power supplies). For a frame of reference: NVIDIA recommends 550 Watts with 40A on the 12V rail for the GeForce GTX 280. Just remember: don't try and buy a cheap generic brand to save some cash, just because it says 1000 Watts (or whatever the number is) doesn't mean it can actually handle that (sadly). Quality counts big, be sure to get a quality power supply or you can face any number of problems.

PC Buyer's Guide - High End

What to look for when buying a motherboard, regardless of chipset or processor it supports:

Share this content